Tuesday, 29 September 2026

Artefact Hunting Vandals Strike Historic Church Site in Britain



Matthew Lockwood, 'Vandals strike historic church site' BBC 21 September 2026. 
Campaigners fighting to save a Grade II listed 15th Century church tower say they are to step up security after the graveyard was vandalised. Hertfordshire Police said holes were dug in the ground of Thundridge Old Church of St Mary and All Saints, near Ware, on 16 August. Officers have released CCTV footage showing a group of men in the area with what appeared to be metal detectors behind them[...] The site is a scheduled monument, and it is illegal to use metal detectors or disturb the ground.
This is a truly disgraceful act of disrespect and a blatant violation of the law. Desecrating a scheduled monument and historical graveyard for selfish plunder not only damages irreplaceable history but also deeply insults the community working tirelessly to preserve it. It is incredibly disheartening to see such disregard for heritage and sacred ground, and those responsible must be held fully accountable. It is time to consider what should be done about the lack of any curbs on artefact hunting and collecting and the unregulated use of metal detectors as current half-measures are doing nothing to curb such selfish behaviour.

STOP - Stop Taking Our Past.



Thursday, 24 September 2026

Rather Optimistic Tekkies Disappointed by no-sale


Two Suffolk artefact hunters will not be able to pay the landowner off just yet (Alice Cunningham,'Medieval gold ring fails to sell at auction', BBC 23/9/2026). The auction was by Noonans Mayfair during a sale featuring a mixed bag: "silver, jewellery, watches, and objects of vertu". The 14th-century gold seal ring was originally uncovered in April 2024 within a ploughed field near Stoke Ash, Suffolk, by two friends, Aaron Pizzey (30) and James Race (39). Although the duo expressed disappointment when the piece failed to reach its £8,500 reserve price, they plan to try selling it at auction again down the road.

Initial estimates valued the ring between £10,000 and £12,000, though the finders had higher hopes of it fetching £25,000 to £30,000 (eh?).

Aaron Pizzey (left) and James Race 

The ring features a carnelian intaglio depicting a griffin, alongside an inscription that presumably identifies its owner. The engraved text reads "GRIFFVnMATILIELEMATILIOVR", which evidently translates to something like "griffin Matilda the maternal countess". It is claimed that this phrasing points toward Matilda of Lancaster, the Countess of Ulster, as the probable owner. Notably, she joined the Augustinian Campsey Priory near Wickham Market as a canoness around 1347–1348, located roughly 20 miles from the discovery site. How true that is is anybody's guess.

The men also managed to find a hoard of 60 gold Roman coins in February in Eye and were similarly going through the treasure process again before hoping to auction them. The Suffolk archaeological heritage is being ripped out of the archaeological record rich and fast now. 


Friday, 28 August 2026

The Lesson of Torchesk

 

                   2026 screenshot (after Sikorski)      

Jerzy Sikorski reports that at the EAA meeting in Athens, in a paper (read by Jens Schneeweiss) on work on the middle Dnipro region in Ukraine, a mention is made of the continuation of the monitoring by drone of the earthwork site at Ol'shanytsya in the southern Porossya area on the Ros' river (Torchesk) begun in 2021 ['Looking Over the shoulder of the 'Black Diggers' of Ukraine', PACHI Saturday, 4 December 2021]. While six years ago there were recorded traces of the digging of over 5000 holes there, apparently the total now is 16000+ and the plan shown at EAA indicates a shocking density of digging and destruction (compare with the 2021 one in my post). This is not only of significance in terms of the site itself and Ukrainian heritage protection in general, it raises the issue that this is (as far as I know, please correct me if I am wrong) a pioneering project, and if such monitoring were to be carried out of 'productive' sites elsewhere (England and Wales for example with the laissez faire legislation in place there) would it reveal a comparable level of destruction? It's easy to assume that "Ukraine is an exception" but how can we complacently assume that it is not? 

Also, if 21 days monitoring six years ago produced evidence of 5100 holes dug in that period, the whole post-harvest and spring metal detecting seasons would have involved even more hole-digging.  If c. 15.5k holes were dug in 2022 [when the war's Front came no nearer than 300km before retreating], 2023, 2024, 2025, and spring 2026, does this represent a slowdown? Could it be that awareness that the site was under intensive monitoring by drone slowed down the attacks of these culture-criminals? Are the young men who'd be searching the site now fighting the occupant? Or is there a feeling among detectorists that with all the searching that has gone on there, the site is largely "searched out" ?





Archaeological Looting in the Republic of Bashkortostan


A recent study (Gizzatov, Tuzbekov and Akhatov 2025) reveals that over 12% of recorded archaeological sites in the Republic of Bashkortostan in the Russian Federation, despite the nominal protection these sites are given by the law of the region, have been damaged by illegal looting. The researchers analyzed data collected between 2017 and 2023 by the Scientific and Production Centre of the Republic of Bashkortostan on the condition of 623 archaeological sites (the work was supported by the Russian Science Foundation under Grant No. 25-18-00270 “Looting in the Urals: development of methods to counteract the destruction of cultural heritage objects). This research revealed a severe threat to local history and cultural artefacts and that looting is as a key factor in the loss of archaeological heritage in the Republic of Bashkortostan. Looters mostly search for metal objects and historical items from the 16th century to the early 20th century. There has been a ninefold increase in the activity of ‘treasure hunters’ since 2010, particularly in the Bashkir Trans-Urals and the northwestern part of the region near the lower parts of the Belaya River. Despite the huge rise in illegal excavations, officials have not recorded a single criminal case against archaeological looters in the region, Russian laws protecting cultural heritage contain contradictions and grey areas, making it hard to punish modern metal-detector looters. As a result of the research, the article proposes improvements to the monitoring system through the use of modern technologies and stricter control over the sale of metal detectors to preserve archaeological heritage. Reference

Gizzatov, D., Tuzbekov, A., and Akhatov, A. (2025). Cultural Heritage Loss Through Archaeological Looting: A Comprehensive Analysis of the Current Situation in the Republic of Bashkortostan. Conservation and Management of Archaeological Sites, 27(3), 195–215.




Thursday, 27 August 2026

Ukrainian Archaeologist: "The Situation of the Archaeological Heritage in Eastern Ukraine is Catastrophic"


Serhiy Telizhenko, Scientific Secretary of the Institute of Archaeology of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Candidate of Historical Sciences carried out research in the Luhansk region until the illegal Russian invasion of the area. He describes the situation with the Ukrainian archaeological heritage in the eastern regions, where fierce fighting is currently taking place, as catastrophic. According to him, many archaeological sites have been significantly damaged, or even irretrievably lost. However, he does not give up hope of returning to his native Luhansk region with new excavations. “We will have to return there. We simply did not have time to explore many things and, I am afraid, we will not have time to do much,” he says. Currently, the scientist works in the West and South of Ukraine.

Археолог Сергій Теліженко: «Ситуація з археологічною спадщиною на Сході України – катастрофічна» [Archaeologist Serhiy Telizhenko: “The situation with the archaeological heritage in Eastern Ukraine is catastrophic”] National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine press release 25.08.2026  катастрофічна». 

Maryna Tereshchenko  “Окопи копають на місці давніх стоянок”: археолог Сергій Теліженко про розкопки у Кремінній та спадщину під вогнем [“Trenches are being dug on the site of ancient sites”: archaeologist Serhiy Telizhenko on excavations in Kreminna and heritage under fire]Tribun August 18, 2026. 

Bronze Age Treasure of Villena Stolen from Archaeological Museum

The Treasure of Villena, one of the most important Bronze Age goldsmithing ensembles in Europe, was stolen in the early hours of this morning (August 27, 2026), from the Archaeological Museum of Villena (Alicante). The thieves were able to steal the 59 pieces of gold, silver, meteoric iron, and amber discovered in 1963, in just four minutes. They bypassed the security systems by taking advantage of a diversionary alarm at a nearby sports complex. This event has left the local population deeply alarmed and has immediately triggered an intense investigation by the Civil Guard and the Judicial Police. 

The robbery adds to a worrying and recent wave of thefts in archaeological museums in Spain (for example at Badajoz and Albacete) and reveals a critical vulnerability in the protection of the Spanish cultural legacy.  

Friday, 14 August 2026

New Study Revealed Looting Continuing in Syria

Jesse Casana et al, Remote Sensing-Based Analysis of Archaeological Site Damage in Syria: Revisiting a Post-War Landscape, Heritage (2026). DOI: 10.3390/heritage9060209

Amy Olson, 'Syria's ancient sites face widespread looting and systematic bulldozing, satellite images reveal'.     

[...] Relying on an expanding suite of satellite imagery resources, this paper presents a renewed analysis of looting and archaeological site damage in Syria over the past decade. The results reveal: (1) severe damage to many sites in northern Syria from a novel form of mechanized looting, (2) intensified impacts from the establishment of military facilities or refugee camps on many prominent sites, and (3) rampant incidents of small-scale looting across all areas of the country. These results highlight the importance of ongoing imagery-based heritage monitoring efforts and will support emerging mitigation, stabilization, and damage assessment efforts in Syria going forward.


 

Sunday, 26 July 2026

The Theft of the Vix Torc

As is being reported in the media, on Friday, July 24, 2026, at approximately 10:30 AM, two thieves paid the admission fee to enter the Musée du Pays Châtillonnais in Châtillon-sur-Seine, Burgundy, extracting the renowned solid-gold torc of the "Lady of Vix". Acting as standard tourists, they bypassed security, shattered the recessed glass display case protecting the 2,500-year-old gold artefact, and fled through the main entrance. Despite recent municipal capital injections of €150,000 to reinforce secure glass fenestration and closed-circuit television (CCTV) arrays, the perpetrators were able to take the artefact in a highly calculated, rapid operation executed before onlookers. The massive, 450-pound bronze Vix krater from the site remained untouched, the 480-gram, 24-karat gold torc was successfully taken. Though a 20-year-old suspect has since been detained by French authorities, the current location of the artefact remains unknown, raising severe concerns regarding its physical preservation and the risk of being melted down.  

This heist is being treated by Europol and French investigators as part of a highly alarming broader trend. It comes less than a year after the armed €88 million heist in October 2025 of imperial crown jewels at the Louvre, and just days after a similar jewelry theft in Langres. Recent intelligence assessments by Europol emphasize that the methodology of cultural property theft is undergoing a profound paradigm shift. Traditional, specialized antiquities trafficking structures are increasingly replaced by opportunistic, decentralized criminal syndicates recruited via digital networks. These actors prioritize immediate commodity liquidization (the weight and purity of precious metals) over the intrinsic historical or artistic value of the object. For the academic and conservation communities, the primary threat is the irreversible loss of material culture through melting. The event underscores an urgent need for institutional reforms, enhanced national security protocols for irreplaceable regional collections, and more aggressive monitoring of both the dark web and physical black markets for early Iron Age materials. It also means that we should be aiming to document in the utmost detail every item threatened with theft through being in public institutions to put on record as full a description as currently possible as a form of preservation by documentation. This should be a priority over the digging up of more material which is then put at risk.

Discovered in 1953 at the base of Mont Lassois, the Vix burial represents one of the most structurally intact and elite Halstatt D3 / La Tène IA (circa 500–450 BCE) Fürstengrab (princely tomb) assemblages ever excavated. The individual interred, traditionally designated as the "Princess" or "Lady" of Vix, was accompanied by a monumental, Mediterranean-imported bronze krater and an array of prestige items that signify complex, trans-Alpine trade systems spanning Hallstatt networks and Greco-Etruscan centres. The stolen torc is a peerless artefact of proto-historic European metalwork.


Monday, 13 July 2026

Trump reduces size of 2 national monuments in Utah



In the USA, President Trump announces that he is terminating 3 million acres of national monuments in southern Utah, opening them up to drilling, mining, and industrial development. These are the largest cuts to public lands in US history. It is not known whether in this case money changed hands and if so, how much. Grand Staircase-Escalante (created under the Antiquities Act by President Bill Clinton in 1996) and Bears Ears (created under the Antiquities Act by President Barack Obama in 2016) are home to significant dinosaur fossils and sacred Native American sites. Trump had taken similar actions during his first term, but those were reversed by President Joe Biden.

In general, Trump administration officials and congressional Republicans have sought to expand drilling, mining and logging on public lands, while removing protections for imperiled species and rolling back rules for conservation.

Monday, 29 June 2026

Native American Public Archaeology under Trump?

 

Watching over the looters' shoulders: "A Digger Hit A Bascom Blade Cache, “4,000 Years,” Then More Blades Were Still In The Dirt". Much hilarity ensues as, with a soundtrack of empty-headed banter from camo-clad seniors, artefact hunters "uncover what looks like a few Bascom blades, but the hole keeps getting better every time they look closer. The count jumps from four to five, then six, then even more pieces appear packed into the same small spot. By the end, the group is staring at a 4,000-year-old cache that feels like the kind of find most artifact hunters never see once".The archaeological context is totally destroyed. "Bascom Blade" is a "collector-type" name and they are found by dumb selfish digging morons like these in the Georgia/North Florida area.

Somerset Hoard acquired for £78,000'

Steven Morris, 'Somerset detectorist strikes gold with ‘spectacular’ Roman ring find' Guardian Tue 2 Jun 2026 .
When Kevin Minto, a lorry driver, former soldier and keen metal detectorist, came upon something glinting in a Somerset field, he thought at first it was a coin – potentially quite interesting, probably not amazing. But the object turned out to be extraordinary: a gold Roman ring, unusually large and exquisitely crafted, set with a finely engraved gemstone depicting the goddess Victoria driving a two-horse chariot.[...] One of the boys I was with was screaming: ‘We’re rich, we’re rich.’”
They had returned to a productive site where coins had previously been found (not considered or reported as a hoard at the time, then left alone).
Minto first found Roman coins at the site near Ilminster in 2017. He kept returning and finding more coins scattered over a wide area, probably by ploughs. “The coins were all over the place,” he said. On another occasion he found a lead-lined coffin. Then in 2018, the ring was discovered. “The money was only paid out a couple of months ago, so it’s taken a long time,” he said. There was a complication, too, because the ring was found on the day of a military veterans’ detecting rally – and there was a dispute about who was entitled to the proceeds. “I’m glad it’s all finished now,” he said.
And that's as far as this reporter takes the story. It seems to me, reading between the lines there isa LOT more he could have done with it, questions to ask. But then dumbdown suits everybody better, the paper has a gap-filler feel-good (ordinary bloke strikes it lucky) story. Win-win as they say, why bother with details and perspective?

It's all very similar to the way these things are now always reported and done. It's just socially acceptable and now there seem to be fewer objections from within pro archaeology or the wider public with an interest in heritage (who now just seem to accept the news reports without question). Shame on the lot of you. 

Hat tip Dave Coward

Sunday, 28 June 2026

"From a Private Collection" How Did it get to New York?

                     Sothebys New York .                  

Colección Mariano Moret @ColeccionMMoret [ Translated from Spanish]
"Despite having spent more than 25 years buying art in the international market and having seen it all, I still find myself amazed when I see pieces as absolutely exceptional as this Roman emperor torso from the Julio-Claudian period (1st century BC) coming from a private collection that @Sothebys will put up for auction next October with an estimated price of 8,000,000 – 12,000,000 USD. We will have to wait for the publication of the catalogue by the auction house to see if data are provided on the provenance of the work."

Sunday, 14 June 2026

Russian Barrage on Civilian Targets Also Damages Kyiv's Historic Dormition Cathedral at the Lavra Monastery


Ukrainian  authorities confirm that Kyiv’s iconic Lavra Monastery was significantly damaged during a Russian drone and missile raid last night. Firefighting efforts to preserve the structure are ongoing. A massive Russian missile and drone attack hit Kyiv overnight into June 15, damaging homes and markets, and cut power to 140,000 residents. The Russians launched more than 60 missiles at civilian sites in the capital alone. In total, 70 missiles and 611 drones were used against Ukraine. While the strike wounded 13-20 people in the city, broader attacks killed at least four elsewhere, including Kharkiv rescuers.

The raid also sparked a fire at the Dormition Cathedral in the 1051-founded Kyiv-Pechersk Lavra, a UNESCO World Heritage site. The roof of the Dormition Cathedral is reportedly ablaze. Clergy have been rescuing holy relics amid the chaos. Ukrainian leaders have called it a brutal assault on heritage and Christianity, one wonders what the world response will be. From the Horde in the 13th century to the Nazis and Bolsheviks in the 20th century, Kyiv’s sacred monasteries have suffered numerous barbaric attacks, now they are the target of Russian terrorists who have already linked crimes against cultural heritage to their attacks on Ukrainian cultural identity.


As per the famous twitter-meme:
Director-General of UNESCO, Khaled El-Enany has not issued an official, standalone quote or statement directly condemning Russia. Will he do it now?

Sunday, 24 May 2026

Fraudster sentenced after trying to sell bogus ancient statues with fake papers to Sotheby’s


A 46-year-old man, Andrew Crowley, was sentenced to two years in prison for attempting to sell fraudulent Cycladic figures at Sotheby’s London using forged 1976 provenance documents that were later identified to use a typeface developed in 2001. Forensic analysis by the Metropolitan Police and FBI revealed the invoices were fakes, and while Crowley claimed the items were inherited, expert evidence deemed the artefacts to be modern reproductions. This case, resulting in a prison sentence and fines, relies on the dealer doing due diligence to uncover the scam and the necessity of rigorous pre-sale provenance research.

Interestingly, in terms of the toolmarks, these counterfeits have been produced by less simplistic methods than many of those that pass for genuine on the market that are machine-carved.

BBC ''Ancient' statues fraud foiled by fake paperwork', 22 May 2026

Nadeem Badshah,'Fraudster sentenced after trying to sell bogus ancient statues with fake papers to Sotheby’s' The Guardian 23 May 2026.

Friday, 1 May 2026

Israel in Lebanon

 

Israeli forces have detonated the historic Shamaa Castle and the shrine of Shamoun al-Safa (St. Peter) in south Lebanon, destroying the UNESCO-protected sites alongside an airstrike on Froun. This follows local reports of multiple deaths in Haboush within the last hour.

The satle is under UNESCO protection

Tuesday, 28 April 2026

Excavation-Permit Flaunting Archaeologist Goes Free

Poland has released Russian archaeologist Alexander Butyagin who was due to be extradited to Ukraine to face charges of carrying out illegal excavations in occupied Crimea. He was arrested while travelling across Europe to give lectures on his work. Butyagin was exchanged at the Belarus–Poland border today in a "five for five" exchange. According to Russian officials, he was exchanged for two officers of Moldova’s special services the Russians had in captivity. Alongside Butyagin the wife of a Russian serviceman in Polish custody was exchanged. Other sources report that activist Andrzej Poczobut was also exchanged. As for Butyagin, he was facing charges of digging stuff out of a site without an excavation permit, and who gives a tinkers about them, eh? If we are not going to respect each others' cultural property legislation, Ukraine should suspend all permits for any current Polish excavations there. Including the controversial Volyn exhumations.


The Wheels of British "Justice" Once More Grind Slowly when Antiquities and the Establishment are Involved

"Great" Britian shows once again  what a load of tossers they are when it comes to chasing up antiquities crime (Craig Simpson 'Academic who exposed British Museum thefts 'annoyed to die before seeing justice' MSN 28/4/2026).

An expert who exposed the theft of hundreds of artefacts from the British Museum was “annoyed” to know he was dying without the case being resolved. The arts and heritage world was scandalised in 2023 when an arrest was made over items stolen from the museum’s collection and sold. There was outrage when it emerged that Dr Ittai Gradel, a Danish academic turned antiquities dealer who has died at 61 from cancer, had raised the alarm as early as 2021. The institution did not act on Dr Gradel’s warning that British Museum items were appearing on an online auction site.
Hat tip Dave Coward

 

Friday, 24 April 2026

The Curse of the Mummy Ring



Celestial Rex, 'The Curse of the Mummy Ring'
"May 2019. A simple click on an online listing, a purchase from a small Canadian museum, and I was holding history in my virtual cart: authentic Egyptian mummy linen, delicate threads woven over two millennia ago, whispering tales from the Ptolemaic Dynasty, the very era of Cleopatra. The museum guaranteed its authenticity, a claim later confirmed by Customs itself. They dated the linen, to approximately 300-30 BCE, a tangible artifact of a lost world. "Able to ship to the USA"!..." [read more here].

Wednesday, 15 April 2026

Drents Museum in Assen Gold Theft, Update [UPDATED]



After over a year's work by the Dutch police, it is reported that the golden Romanian helmet of Coțofenești that was stolen in 2025 from a museum in the Netherlands, has been recovered, along with 2 golden bracelets. The helmet was described as "slightly dented, but can be fully restored". This came after a deal of some kind was made with the suspects. Apparantly, one of the suspects did not agree to the deal. That's why the third golden bracelet is still missing.  On 5 June 2026, Dutch media reported that one of the thieves, sentenced that day to nearly four years in prison, had used the infamy of the theft to sell merchandise referencing it, including T-shirts bearing an image of the golden helmet of Cotofenești.

Kirby, Paul "Ancient golden helmet recovered more than a year after Dutch heist".  BBC, 2 April 2026. 


Monday, 13 April 2026

On the US Bombing Iran

 

This young lady from TicTok has an important message for Trump, the cognitively-challenged guy who struggles to construct a coherent sentence and commits crimes against the English language daily (from 'Just human being' justhuman_being7).

@justhuman_being7 #tiktokviral #tiktokindia #tiktokpakistan #tiktok?bangladesh🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩 #tiktokmalaysia ♬ Hard News - DM Production


Monday, 6 April 2026

Cultural Property in War, 2026


 Not so long ago, American academics and heritage professionals were eager to leap in and tell Syrians and Ukrainians how to protect their own heritage by getting grant money and setting up in the USA various judgemental monitoring groups and even 'command centres'  to engage their MAGA-like fantasies about being the world policeman (such as the Virginia/Smithsonian "Cultural Heritage Monitoring Lab"). And there was Stae Department money for this. Now that the United States of America is - together with its genocidal partner Israel - (again) the aggressor in the Middle East, one wonders whether US academics will be standing up actively for the heritage of Iran as their president issues a warning to bomb civilian targets in his illegal war ( Donald J. Trump @realDonaldTrump Apr 04, 2026, 4:05 PM " Remember when I gave Iran ten days to MAKE A DEAL or OPEN UP THE HORMUZ STRAIT. Time is running out - 48 hours before all Hell will reign (sic!) down on them. Glory be to GOD! President DONALD J. TRUMP"). Or will they sit quietly by complicitly this time?

Saturday, 21 March 2026

Missile Attack on Old Jerusalem

 

A missile has just struck Jerusalem’s Old City, very near to the Western Wall, Al-Aqsa Mosque, and the Church of the Holy Sepulchre (all UNESCO World Heritage sites), some of the holiest sites to Jews, Muslims, and Christians. Questions are raised about whether it was launched by Iraq, or was a provocative false flag operation by US-allied Israel, but highlighhts the dangers not only to people but valuable heritage sites caused by the United States' unprovoked and illegal attack on Iran.

UNESCO, being about as useful as a wet paper bag in a supermarket as per usual, has made no response as yet to these effects of the actions of these two terrorist states out of control and threatening world peace.



.

Friday, 20 March 2026

These Ancient Sites are in Jeopardy


In the southwestern Amazon, one archeologist is fighting to protect ancient sites from Brazil’s seemingly unstoppable agribusiness industry, now worth $524 billion. The carvings are proof of an ancient and sophisticated civilization that aligned its agricultural calendar with summer and winter solstices. Farmers view the land as a cash cow, and the area’s historic geometric earthworks are in the way.

.

.

Wednesday, 18 March 2026

Arrested Russian archaeologist wanted in Ukraine for Activities in occupied Crimea Will Probably be Extradited



Kate Tsurkan, 'Poland approves Russian archaeologist's extradition to Ukraine over work in occupied Crimea' Kyiv Independent March 18, 2026

A Polish court, acting on Ukraine’s request, has approved the extradition of Russian archaeologist Aleksander Butyagin to face charges over his activites in occupied Crimea. Butyagin’s arrest has clearly already had a chilling effect on academics in the Russian Federation.  At the end of January 2026, they were advised by Russia’s ministry of science and higher education to carefully assess whether they should travel to any of those countries in the EU, G7 and one or two others who have, in full accordance with international law, sanctioned Russia over its war of aggression against Ukraine.  Butyagin was arrested in Warsaw on 4th December 2025, Butyagin had been travelling around Europe giving public talks to Russian-speaking audiences. He was aware that a Kyiv court had issued a warrant for his arrest in April 2025 - but arrogantly assumed that he would not be arrested in the European Union. Since his arrest, he's been held in a Warsaw prison for allegedly conducting illegal excavations and plundering artefacts from the ancient city of Myrmekion in Crimea - Ukraine's peninsula annexed by Russia in 2014.
A senior scholar at the Hermitage, Russia's largest art museum in St Petersburg, he has since 1999 overseen the museum's excavations of Myrmekion, an ancient Greek settlement founded in Crimea in the 6th Century BC. Initially, his research was authorised by Ukraine. But when Russia annexed the peninsula in March 2014, the work continued without Kyiv's consent and carried on after the full-scale invasion eight years later. He could face a jail term of up to five years if found guilty of plundering artefacts, including 30 gold coins, resulting in damage estimated at more than $4.5m (£3.4m) [...] Russia's excavations in Crimea are illegal under the 2nd protocol to The Hague Convention for the protection of cultural property in the event of armed conflict. Ukraine and most European countries are parties to the protocol, but Russia is not.
But that is no excuse for ignoring Ukrainian law on territory that still belongs to Ukraine (though Russia - alone - contests that). The archaeologist should have thought twice before entering an illegally occupied territory for excavations. It is highly problematic, both legally and ethically. To put that in context, it has been pointed out by Vladimir Tikhonov in Oslo that, principles aside, in reality he had few alternative choices:
"Had he, a researcher at a state museum, protested the illegal annexation, he would have been fired and either arrested or forced into exile - from which he wouldn't have had any opportunities to do excavations on Russia-controlled territory. Could we, who (luckily) never faced a choice of this kind, blame him for his conformism? Could I myself choose principles rather than continuation of a research career in such a situation?"
Butyagin is currently in a detention centre in Warsaw, and a motion to release him on bail has been turned down. He is appealing the extradition.

Update 21.3.2026

Reportedly, the Russian government has officially submitted draft law No. 1181659-8 to the State Duma, allowing the extraterritorial use of the Russian Armed Forces by presidential decision to "protect" Russians detained, held, or prosecuted abroad under decisions of foreign or international courts whose jurisdiction Moscow does not recognize.

.

Sunday, 15 March 2026

More Cultural Crimes in US 'Epstein Raids'



As reported by Iranwire, as a result of the ongoing illegal US and Israeli bombing raids a number of Iran’s historic buildings have been damaged or destroyed. These include the Golestan Palace-Museum and parts of the historic fabric of central Tehran, the Asef, Salar Said, and Khosroabad mansions in Sanandaj, the Rashk-e Janan Palace (Governorate Palace), Chehel Sotoun Palace, Ali Qapu Palace, and the Shah Mosque of Isfahan. The Anthropology and Archaeology Museum located in Falak-ol-Aflak Castle in Khorramabad has also reportedly been damaged during the attacks. This must stop.

Friday, 13 March 2026

Israel Continues its Eighty Year Habit of Being the Aggressor State



Israel is using the cover of the Iran war to empty out southern Lebanon in the same way as they have made a desolation (the real meaning of the word "shoah" שׁוֹאָה) of Gaza. Civilians are being pushed north while the area is framed as a “buffer zone”. It looks like they are aiming for a border on the line of the northern edge of Mandatory Palestine. This aligns with their continued deliberate distortion of the wording of the Balfour Declaration, where they take "homeland... in Palestine" to mean a "state" (which it does not) covering all of Palstine (which is not the meaning of the preposition "in"). The document specifically stipulated that “nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine”.

Israeli expansionism will not stop at South Lebanon unless they are stopped. The world must not allow Israel to ignore existing boundaries (lilke Russia has done in Ukraine) and steal Palestine and Lebanon. What we need is a strong international body to which aggressor states should be accountable, sort of like an organization of "united nations" maybe? Now where could we find such a body prepared to act in the interests not only of the displaced people,* but of world peace in general?


*after all, where are those people, after the fleeing Gazans, goiung to go? Is there room in Europe andnorthern America to accomodate them? Will they be welcome there?

Sunday, 8 March 2026

Casualties of War [updated]


For four years now, the US has steadfastly failed to react in any meaningful way to the striking of civilian targets in Ukraine by the Russian Federation, residential districts, schools, hospitals, infrastructure, all are being destroyed in an attempt to wear the people down, make them see resistance to occupation and repression as futile. The inability of the Americans to see this as the horror that it is, to question the pro-Putin propaganda has puzzled all who thought of America as a place full of decent people, just like us.

That is is not, or no longer is, is shown by what they and their Israeli puppetmasters are going after in their illegal war on Iran. Although there is very clear censorship of the news in our media, more relaible reports show that so far at least 1,230 people have already been killed in Iran since start of war. The death toll includes dozens of schoolchildren killed in a strike on Shajareh Tayyebeh elementary school in Minab, southern Iran on Saturday (unconfirmed figures suggest that up to 168 children and 14 teachers were killed by the strike and 95 injured). Reuters confirmed that the school was bombed TWICE by the US military, 40 minutes apart, to make sure that the hit affected rescue workers and horrified parents who had arrived at the site to find out what had happened to their kids. This was intentional. You don't "accidentally" bomb a school TWO TIMES. It was a massacre. This is the greatest number of civilians killed by the US military since the My Lai Massacre in the Vietnam War.
Subsequently, another three schools have reportedly been hit for some reason by Israeli and US missiles: Two schools in Parand, southwest of Tehran, hit by missiles and Shahid Hamedani School – Tehran (Niloufar Square). The World Health Organisation (which of course the isolationist USA is no longer a member of) reports that Israel and the USA have already bombed 13 hospitals in Iran. Hospitals, that is a war-crime. You can tell Israel is running this war, it's the exact same tactics as Gaza, kill the children.


As far as cultural heritage goes, almost certainly the bombing campaign in Tehran is going to result in enormous destruction. The 18th century Golestan Palace built by the Qajar Turk dynasty, is known as one of Iran's iconic buildings with its diamonds and mirrors. This complex combines traditional Persian architecture with western influences and is on the UNESCO World Heritage List. It was damaged by US/Israeli bombing on March 2nd. Iran has formally notified UNESCO Director-General of serious damage to the Golestan Palace and parts of Tehran’s Grand Bazaar following these unlawful military attacks by the United States and the Israeli regime. The Israeli military has already destroyed or damaged over 70% of Gaza's archaeological sites and historic monuments. Now, together with the US military, they are destroying Iran's cultural heritage.

UPDATE 11th March 2026
The US and Israel have reportedly struck another girls’ school in Iran. The airstrikes this morning on Khomeyn, central Iran, struck the Shaghayegh Girls' School. There were again two airstrikes within minutes, indicating a double-tap. According to UNICEF the U.S. has already hit 20 schools, 10 hospitals, and killed over 1,300 civilians including 300 children. The United States Trump Administration is a terrorist regime.


According to the Iranian Red Crescent, the US-Israeli forces have already bombed for no particular reason over 20,000 non-military buildings in Iran 17,353 were people's homes.

Thursday, 5 March 2026

Trump Fires 'Cosplay Barbie' from DHS



There are changes at the top of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). It will no longer be led by the scandal-prone Kristi Noem (in post from January 2025 to 5th March 2026). Within it, Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), is the primary U.S. federal agency responsible for investigating the illicit trade in cultural property, art, and antiquities. During Noem's tenure as the 8th Secretary of Homeland Security, she oversaw Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), which includes HSI. HSI operates the Cultural Property, Art, and Antiquities (CPAA) program, which focuses on identifying and repatriating stolen or looted cultural heritage.

While Noem's public priorities heavily emphasized immigration enforcement, border security, and dismantling human trafficking and drug smuggling networks, HSI continued its long-standing mandate to target transnational criminal organizations involved in diverse forms of illicit trade, including antiquities.

Noem was removed from her position as Secretary on March 5, 2026 (together with Corey Lewandowski - whose Polish-origin name most journalists had extreme difficulty prononuncing properly, former Trump campaign manager and latterly powerful "special government employee" (SGE) and de facto chief of staff to Noem). President Trump has nominated Senator Markwayne Mullin to succeed her (Noem reportedly has been appointed to a new role as "Special Envoy for The Shield of the Americas" where she will no dounbbt find much scope to continue the cosplay activities for which she gained notoriety). Mullin is of Native American origin, he is a member of the Cherokee Nation.

Monday, 2 March 2026

US-Israel Strikes Hit Historic Monument


Reports from Tehran say the UNESCO-listed Golestan Palace has been damaged by recent bombardments. It seems that as far as the US is concerned, cultural heritage on Iranian territory is a valid target. All parties must respect international humanitarian law and protect World Heritage for future generations. Well, of course Philistine-USA left UNESCO last year.

Most Common Iranian Artefacts on the Antiquities Market


                Mina'i ware bowl (wikipedia)              

The United States and Israel have started a war with Iran without, it now seems any clear preparration for the consequences. As with Iraq in 2003, planning for the aftermath is non-existant and the direction of this conflict is very unclear. Meanwhile, apart from the human costs of Trump's rashness, the effects on the cultural environment are going to be severe. Here I just want to consider the portable antiquities. At present, archaeological materials from the Iranian plateau have a long history of appearing in international markets. The illegal trade in these cultural goods is already a highly lucrative global industry.

Luristan Bronzes (c. 2500–700 BCE): Perhaps the most prolific Iranian artefacts on the market, these bronze objects (including horse bits, pins, cups, and animal figures) first flooded international markets in the late 1920s after being discovered by local farmers in the Zagros Mountains. They have became so abundant that they are popular acquisitions by numerous private collectors and major museums worldwide. A lot of what is offered as "Luristan" is not from tha region/culture at all, and a high quantity on the market at the (pre-US war) moment is fake, with a variety of artificial patinas.

Achaemenid Empire (c. 550–330 BCE): Metalwork from this era, such as gold and silver jewellery, coins, and copper alloy items like arrowheads and pins, is highly sought after globally. These artifacts are valued for their craftsmanship and connection to the first major world empire.

Elamite Civilization (c. 2700–539 BCE): Elamite artifacts common in the trade include painted pottery, limestone and terracotta sculptures, and cylinder seals made of materials like lapis lazuli and chalcedony. A significant amount of unclassified Elamite material from earlier excavations remains unaccounted for or in vulnerable storage.

Jiroft Culture (Bronze Age, c. 3000 BCE): This previously unknown civilization was discovered in 2001 after flash floods in the Helil River Valley exposed ancient cemeteries. Mysterious chlorite artifacts began appearing on the antiquities market shortly after (... ahem...), leading to the identification of the site.

Sassanid Period (224–651 CE) : Artefacts from this period are perhaps not very prominent on the Market at the moment, but there is increasing interest in the glassware. In addition to ancient archaeological artifacts, several other categories of high-value cultural heritage are frequently found on the global market. These items are particularly susceptible to being smuggled when national oversight is compromised:

Persian Manuscripts and Calligraphy: Iranian manuscripts are highly sought after for their artistic and historical value, frequently appearing in auction houses like Sotheby's and Christie's (for example recent sales of ilustrated copies and pages of copies of the Shahnameh (Book of Kings) and the Khamseh of Nizami). These mss feature elaborate calligraphy (Nasta'liq script), miniature paintings with vibrant opaque colours, and "unvan" (illuminated headpieces) in gold and ultramarine (lapis lazuli). Single folios torn by destructive bastards out of mss are often more common than complete codices because they are easier to smuggle and sell individually.

Glazed Decorative Tiles Tiles are frequently "harvested" from religious and historical buildings. Common Types are Lajvardina and Lustreware tiles from the Ilkhanid and Seljuk periods (12th–14th centuries), which are highly prized by collectors. Historical tiles are sometimes declared as "modern copies" at customs to bypass export bans.

Antique Persian Carpets While the modern carpet trade is legal, high-end antique carpets are frequently targets for illicit export. Common Types: Kashan, Tabriz, Isfahan, and Kerman carpets from the 16th to 19th centuries. High-end pieces often use silk foundations and asymmetric "Persian knots" to achieve extremely high knot densities.

Metalwork and Ceramics Various types, such as lustre pottery, medieval ceramics from cities like Kashan for exammple, among the metalwork, Qajar Enamels: 18th and 19th-century enamelled gold and silver objects.

In light of current regional instability, we can expect looting and smuggling to intensify. Monuments and outdoor sculptures etc. of course could be damaged by shelling, bombing or vandalism, such non-movable objects are frequently protected only by sandbags, making them vulnerable to strikes and subsequent looting of fragments.

We may also see an increase in illegal eExcavations: as we have seen recently in the Middle East especoially, economic collapse and social upheaval often drive local populations toward "graverobbing" or unauthorized digging. I

Historic precedents suggest that conflict-zone artefacts are often laundered through existing legal markets. For example, Israeli dealers were previously used to launder thousands of stolen cuneiform tablets from other Middle Eastern conflict zones for sale to U.S. collectors. Funding for Militant Groups: Trafficking in "blood antiquities" can represent a significant portion of revenue for militant groups and organized crime.

It remains to be seen, given the current wave of cultural philistinism and interference coupled with money-cutting in foreign policy of the Trump White House, whether the State Department will be able top put any measures in place to help prevent the US dealers and collectors getting mixed up in the passage of illicit artefacts that this war may generate. They really should.

Saturday, 28 February 2026

'Luristan' Bronzes seized in USA


Press Release, 'Philadelphia CBP officers intercept Bronze Age swords and arrowheads from the northeastern region of Iran' 02/27/2026. U.S. Customs and Border Protection officers intercepted a shipment of ancient artefacts being smuggled through Philadelphia International Airport. The swords and arrowheads date back to the Bronze Age, almost 4,000 years ago.
The shipment initially arrived on an express delivery flight from the United Arab Emirates on Oct. 16. It was destined to an address in Jacksonville, Fla. CBP officers x-rayed the shipment, which was manifested as metal decoration articles, and detected sword-like objects. Officers then opened the shipment and discovered the swords and arrowheads. Officers suspected the items to be cultural artifacts and detained the shipment for further investigation. CBP officers contacted the National Targeting Center’s Antiquities Unit, which solicited assistance from an archaeologist affiliated with a local Philadelphia university with extensive experience working in the Middle East. On Feb. 13, the archaeologist authenticated the short swords and arrowheads as antiquities dating back to the later 2nd millennium BCE, 1600-1000 BCE, from an area along the southwestern Caspian Sea near the lush Talish Mountains region of Iran. The antiquities are suspected to have been derived from illicit excavations of burial sites. CBP officers will safeguard the antiquities until a disposition is ordered.

Not mentioned is the fact that the items however seem to be wrapped in Korean newspaper. There are quite a few antiques dealers and estate sales auctioneers in Jacksonville, north Florida, but no 'gallery' antiquities dealer that has come under my radar (yet) as dodgy. Maybe the buyer is an eBayer or social media seller. 



It is not a little suspicious that the blade weapons have closely similar patinas, yet would have been recovered from different soil conditions, depending on where the grave was dug, how deep it was, and where the bronze was in relation to other items in the grave/burial deposit. The projectile points have an even more closely similar (but different) patina.  I'd love to know whether we have a transit pattern that goes (instead of Iran....), Thailand fakers to Korean wholesaler to UAE dodgy dealer to the USA. Or maybe these are actual Iranian pieces that have been stripped and repatinated (there is a well-known British seller - ahem, who frequently has multiple items that look like that is what they might be [though they too could equally be out-and-out fakes]).


 

Sunday, 22 February 2026

US Cultural Property Looted, Melted Down


US collectors of looted and smuggled portable antiquities often stress that these items are being "preserved" by being held in US collections, where they are allegedly "safer" than if they had been left in the ground among the brown-skinned folk whose heritage they are. Meanwhile, in the USA, a federal judge has sentenced the mastermind of a sprawling, multi-state museum theft ring to ten years in prison, bringing a dramatic chapter of cultural destruction to a close. The investigation was led by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, alongside state and local law enforcement agencies across Pennsylvania, New York, New Jersey, Rhode Island, North Dakota, and beyond (' Mastermind of multi-state museum theft ring sentenced to 10 years for melting down sports history' River Reporter, February 21, 2026 ).

On February 10, 2026, Senior U.S. District Judge Malachy E. Mannion handed down a 120-month sentence to Nicholas Dombek, 55, of Thornhurst Township, Pennsylvania. The sentencing followed a nearly month-long trial in 2025 that ended with a jury convicting Dombek on multiple felony counts, including conspiracy, theft of major artwork, concealment and disposal of major artwork, and interstate transportation of stolen property.

According to U.S. Attorney Brian D. Miller, Dombek led an eight-person conspiracy responsible for a string of thefts stretching across at least five states. The targets were not random. The group focused on museums, halls of fame, historic estates, specialty galleries, and local businesses—institutions dedicated to preserving fine art, sports heritage, antique firearms, rare minerals, and other culturally significant artefacts.

In total, the ring stole or disposed of dozens of historically important objects over more than a decade. The financial damage alone exceeded $2.7 million in restitution, but the cultural loss was far greater. Many of the stolen works were irreplaceable pieces of American artistic, cultural and athletic history.

What makes the case especially disturbing is not just the theft, but what happened afterward. Rather than reselling the items intact on the collectors’ market, the conspirators frequently destroyed them. After transporting the stolen artifacts back to northeastern Pennsylvania (often to Dombek’s residence), they melted down metal objects into crude discs or bars. These were then sold as raw material to fences in the New York City area for a fraction of their historical and market value.

In at least one case, a valuable painting was deliberately burned to prevent investigators from recovering it as evidence. Many other objects remain missing.

The conspiracy began to unravel after law enforcement executed a search warrant at Dombek’s home in 2019. Prosecutors later revealed that he attempted to intimidate co-conspirators to prevent cooperation with authorities. In 2023, after being indicted, he fled when federal agents tried to arrest him and remained a fugitive for nearly six months before surrendering on New Year’s Day 2024.
Several co-defendants were also convicted and sentenced to prison terms ranging from probation to eight years. Others pleaded guilty earlier in 2025. Nobody is believed to have been shot in the investigations.

In a statement, Wayne A. Jacobs of FBI Philadelphia emphasized the complexity of art crime investigations, noting that such cases often cross jurisdictions and unfold over many years.

Are Archaeologists Talking About Looting?


Naomi Oosterman and Cara Grace Tremain, 'Are Archaeologists Talking About Looting? Reviewing Archaeological and Anthropological Conference Proceedings from 1899–2019' International Journal of Cultural Property Volume 30 Issue 4, 14 May 2024
Abstract
The impetus for this study was a review of the Society for American Archaeology (SAA) 86th Annual Meeting program in 2021. Finding that no single poster or presentation referenced looting or antiquities trafficking despite these issues being ethical considerations that all SAA members are expected to recognize, we sought to investigate whether this was an irregularity – perhaps due to the virtual format of the meeting – or whether it was more common than not. For a broader understanding of if, how, and where these topics are discussed by archaeologists outside of the SAA, we expanded the investigation and studied the archives of 14 other archaeological and anthropological conferences. The results of the study show that despite there being an overall increase in mentioning looting and antiquities trafficking at conferences, it remains a niche and infrequently discussed topic.

Wednesday, 18 February 2026

Ukraine: Fifth Century Disc Brooch Seized by Police

 

                                 State Prosecutor                                 

Prosecutors in Lviv Oblast have brought a case to court concerning the attempted sale of a 5th-century archaeological object of considerable significance: a silver fibula brooch with a gilded surface (Намагався продати фібулу-брошку V ст.: судитимуть мешканця Борислава 17.11.2025). The announcement, published on the website of the Lviv Regional Prosecutor’s Office, outlines yet another instance in which an important early medieval find was diverted toward the antiquities market rather than reported through proper heritage channels.

According to investigators, the object was discovered in March 2025 by a 45-year-old local resident near Boryslav, not far from the Tysmenytsia River. The artefact has been identified as a silver fibula dating to the second half of the 5th century. Under Ukrainian law, such a find is classified as treasure and is considered state property due to its special historical, scientific, artistic, and cultural value. Fibulae of this period are not merely decorative items; they are key chronological and cultural markers, often associated with elite dress and identity in the turbulent centuries that followed the decline of Roman authority in the region.

Rather than notifying the relevant cultural heritage authorities, the man allegedly offered the brooch for sale through an online auction platform. As in similar cases, the act of commercialization without reporting the find forms the basis of the criminal charge. He is accused under Part 1 of Article 193 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, which addresses the illegal appropriation of discovered treasure possessing particular historical, scientific, artistic, or cultural significance.

The brooch has since been seized and transferred for safekeeping to the National Museum of the History of Ukraine, where it will be preserved and studied in a proper institutional context. The case has now been referred to court, and proceedings are ongoing in accordance with Ukrainian law.

The case underscores a familiar problem: even a single object, when removed from its archaeological context and placed on the market, represents not only a legal violation but also the loss of irreplaceable contextual information. The recovery of the fibula ensures its preservation, but the circumstances of its discovery—unrecorded and undocumented—inevitably leave gaps in the historical record that no subsequent legal action can fully repair.

To be honest though, I am a bit puzzled by this find, the titchy photo does not help. It is a small disc brooch ('button brooch'?) with a circumferentially-grooved rim and what looks like tow opposed pairs ofr relief spirals, a four-spiral disc brooch? It looks very similar to Anglo-Saxon ones that have five or six spirals generally, there are some merovingian ones... and....? I cannot really place it among the other stuff from eastern Europe in general. Is it an import? An 'out of place' artefact (displaced by the antiquities market or misreported findspot)? or a fake? What is it? Anybody?






Evacuating Ukraine's Ancient Stone Guardians


According to the Facebook page of the 25th Separate Airborne Sicheslav Brigade (18/2/2026), soldiers of the Sicheslav Brigade, together with museum workers, volunteers, and philanthropists, evacuated from Vasylivka in the Synelnykivskyi District of Dnipropetrovsk Oblast the Polovtsian Babas of the XI–XIII centuries – unique stone monuments of the steppe era.

Previously, as reported by the online media Suspilne, Ukrainian paratroopers and historians had also evacuated two ancient Polovtsian statues from Petropavlivka in the Dnipropetrovsk region, to the same museum to protect them from war damage (Ukrainian Paratroopers Evacuate Ancient Polovtsian Statues from Petropavlivka Mezha, 13 November 2025)
soldiers of the 25th Separate Airborne Brigade, together with historians, evacuated two Polovtsian baba statues as the front line approached: the distance from the settlement to the combat zone exceeded 45 kilometers.
Two statues were saved thanks to the efforts of volunteers and specialists. The artifacts were found on the community’s territory, previously stored under a concrete layer. Nina Sergienko noted that this is not a common practice for artifacts, but in this case such a step helped preserve them from destruction. [...] To move the sculptures to Dnipro, heavy machinery was employed – a truck and a crane. A representative of the 25th Separate Airborne Brigade, Valeriy Kasianenko, said that the soldiers had a clear view of how the Russian army was destroying historical monuments amid active hostilities, so they decided to help with the evacuation.
“We understand that Russia is waging war against Ukraine on different levels, including at the level of history. For us it is important to preserve the heritage of our nation and not let the Russians destroy, damage, or take it for themselves”.
The statues were delivered to the museum in Dnipro. According to the representative, the evacuation lasted almost seven hours, and the transport covered more than 120 kilometers. After the work is completed, the exhibits are planned to be kept at the Dnipro Historical Museum named after Dmytro Yavornytsky. Yuriy Fanihin, Deputy Director for Records and Preservation of Museum Valuables, said that since the start of the large-scale invasion, 27 stone statues have been evacuated. [...] The museum owner added that until the end of the war these exhibits will remain in the museum’s courtyard, after which they will be returned to Petropavlivka."
Polovtsian stone stelae, popularly known as "babas" (from the Turkic word baba, meaning "ancestor"), are unique anthropomorphic monuments created by nomadic Turkic peoples between the 9th and 13th centuries. These statues, carved from sandstone or limestone, were typically placed atop kurgans (burial mounds) as memorial markers to honor the deceased and serve as ritual sites for ancestor worship. Though they represent both male and female figures with intricate details of clothing and weaponry, their primary function was to act as spiritual guardians of the Pontic-Caspian steppe. Today, they remain vital archaeological evidence of the medieval nomadic cultures that once dominated the vast plains of modern-day Ukraine and southern Russia.

My problem with this is that this is treated as a portable antiquities issue (by portableising the "art"). The baba however sits in a site in the context of other things deposited or present at that site - such as a burial, or ephemeral traces of offerings and commemorative rituals at various times. By digging them out roughly and loading them on a truck, any traces areound the base of the stone will have been losgt, the whole site disrupted. "Puttiung it back" is not going to undo that destruction of evidence.

More Accusations of Finds Going Missing When in Hands of the PAS


If reports coming in are true, things look pretty rotten in UK archaeology. Coming soon after the scandal where finds went missing from a museum storeroom while the PAS was processing some potential Treasure cases (which we're not supposed to talk about because again no charges were ever pressed - shhhhhh) we are told of yet another case. Artefact hunter "Stu" left a comment on my post 'More UK Detectorists Reporting Objects Missing When Curated by Portable Antiquities Scheme' (PACHI ):
I've just had some pieces returned. Lithics. There was a beautiful scraper in amongst them with gorgeous fossil inclusions. It's been taken and replaced with a broken shard of flint that i did not recover. It was not present when they were handed over. Someone has cherry picked the piece and switched it out with a piece that i definitely did not find. I know because everything was photographed before it was submitted. I won't be handing anything else in to Lancashire PAS in the future.
PAS has been approached for comment, but at the time of writing, no response has been received.
It is hard to say quite what the truth is here, whether the find was somehow nicked or mislaid, or simply bundled up with somebody else's finds and they ended up keeping it. The thing is there is clearly a need for PAS to look at its procedures. Will they? How many times does this in fact happen in a year? Where and how?



Monday, 16 February 2026

So, What IS Going on in the British Museum?


William Dalrymple @DalrympleWill (16/2/2026)
"I've just been chatting with Nick Cullinan, the excellent new director of the British Museum, and I'm very relieved to say that the story put by the Daily Telegraph about the BM cancelling the name Palestine is a complete misrepresentation of the facts:
"To reassure you we are not removing mention from Palestine from our labels," Nick told me. "Indeed, we have a display on at the moment about Palestine and Gaza.
"I know this is something our curators have thought long and hard about - as you can imagine. We amended two panels in our ancient Levant gallery last year during a regular gallery refresh, when some wording was amended to reflect historical terms.
"To be honest, the even more frustrating and concerning thing is that I knew nothing about this until yesterday and has only been explained to me this morning. I hadn’t even seen that [UK Lawyers for Israel] letter despite asking for it until this morning. I’m disgusted by the whole thing."
The question remains why the Daily Telegraph would put out such a mischief-making story without first fact checking it with the Directors office."

But it's not the Telegraph is it? The story appears to have originated with UK Lawyers for Israel 'British Museum Reviewing Palestine Terminology in Galleries after Audience Testing', February 14, 2026
"The British Museum has confirmed that it is reviewing and updating some gallery panels and labels after “Audience testing has shown that the historic use of the term Palestine … is in some circumstances no longer meaningful.” [...] In a letter to the British Museum, UKLFI explained ...[...].
UKLFI argued that ...[...]
UKLFI requested that the Museum review its collections and revise terminology ...[...]
Responding to the concerns, the British Museum’s spokesperson [unnamed] confirmed that the Museum was in the processes of reviewing and updating panels and labels on a case-by-case basis" [....] A UKLFI spokesperson said: “We welcome the British Museum’s willingness to review and amend terminology.
So, surely some misunderstanding. You'd think lawyers would make sure they are speaking to a spokesperson who knows what's what.

Palestine for the Palestinians.

Sunday, 15 February 2026

UK Treasure Hunting, Bottle-Digging History Prof Flogs off Protohistoric Hoard

                      .                     

A professor of medieval history, Tom Licence of the University of East Anglia, while out artefact hunting near Bury St Edmunds, suffolk with a metal detector, dug blindly down into the archaeological record and uncovered a hoard of 18 Iron Age gold coins  ( Rachael McMenemy, 'History professor finds huge Iron Age hoard' BBC 14.02.2026). The coins date to the reign of Dubnovellaunos, ruler of the Trinovantes tribe between 25 BC and AD 10. Now he and the landowner are flogging off this archaeological material, marketed as 'the Bury St Edmunds Hoard', and the find is expected to brinmg them in £25,000 at auction through Noonans. He first uncovered 17 full gold Iron Age coins and one quarter‑coin in autumn 2024, followed by one more full coin when he returned a few months later – bringing the total to 18. The hoard will be sold at auction by Noonans in London on Wednesday 4 March

PAS record ID: SF-03C894. Nota bene., the record was made in Feb 2025 and contains 17, not the 18 coins. The PAS record is a bit of a mess.

Interestingly, although mention is made in the University's report of the discovery of finding some "pieces of Viking hack silver" in the field on the day of the find of the first coins, the PAS does not seem to have a record of this, what is going on?

What is striking—and frankly disheartening—is not simply that this hoard was removed from its burial context and situational associtions (which was...?) in such a disruptive manner, but that it was done by someone (who bloody well should be) fully aware of the importance of historical context. In the case of this find, and all the others this guy has been hoiking out of the ground as he fancies, they have lost most of their context, apart from the contexts he grabbed these trophy collectable from having lost part of their content. Archaeology is not treasure hunting, the true value of such a hoard lies not in the gold content or auction estimate, but in its precise location, stratigraphy, and association with surrounding material evidence. Once objects are extracted without controlled excavation, irreplaceable contextual data is lost forever. The coins might have contributed to a deeper understanding of ritual deposition practices in late pre-Roman Britain, or the site where they were found. Yet instead of being investigated through a systematic archaeological dig, the site became a metal-detecting success story.

Even more uncomfortable is the romantic language used to frame the discovery. The suggestion that the coins might have belonged to one of his “ancestors” personalizes and sentimentalizes what should be treated as shared cultural heritage. This is not a family heirloom rediscovered in an attic; it is part of the collective archaeological record of Iron Age Britain.

Although the find was reported under the Portable Antiquities Scheme and some funds may be donated to a public collection, this does not undo the damage done by removing the hoard outside a controlled research framework. Recording an object after extraction is not the same as documenting its full archaeological context before disturbance.

It is genuinely sad to see a history professor participating in (and publicly celebrating) activities that contribute to the erosion of archaeological evidence and thus the historical record in general. Scholars, above all, should understand that context is everything. These are the people that should be opinion-makers/informers. This one's got it all wrong.

Professor Tom Licence is shown on his university's website to be a Professor of Medieval History and Literature, School of Literature, Drama and Creative Writing Member, specialist in the Norman Conquest, the cult of the saints, ecclesiastical history and Latin literature (10th-12th centuries). He's written over thirty books, research papers and other texts, including one on dump-digging (2017) [incongruously refereing to Victorian dumps as a 'resource' but seemingly unconcerned about the hobby that is digging them up for profit and pleasure destroying that resource, making then unavailable for future research]. He also wrote a book: "What the Victorians Threw Away". Licence is also a Fellow of the Society of Antiquaries, because, of course he is.

The University of East Anglia's very proud of what he's done: "History professor strikes gold with remarkable Iron Age discovery" by: University of East Anglia Communications Thursday 12 February 2026.
 
Creative Commons License
Ten utwór jest dostępny na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa-Bez utworów zależnych 3.0 Unported.