Sunday, 5 February 2012

US Academic Opposes Italian Repatriation

.
In the comments section of a Planet Princeton article 'Princeton University Returns Art to Italy', Florida-based US academic Dr Robert Steven Bianchi („Ancient Egyptian, Greek, and Roman art and archaeology, modern art” "President at Bianchi Associates, Inc" and a Lecturer in the firm "Archaeological Tours") reacted in the same way as many collectors' lobbyists:
The repatriation of these objects is absurd in the extreme. The Italians boast of their ability to repatriate works of art but simultaneously cannot manage their vast cultural heritage. The deplorable conditions at Pompeii and the condition of the sites in Rome itself, particularly that of the Colosseum are but two examples of the hypocrisy – the Italians cannot take care of their own so they launch witch hunts against those who cherish, protect, preserve, and educate the world about that heritage in order to conceal their own disregard for and indifference toward their own cultural property.
The objects in question were returned to Italy it seems in absence of any evidence that they had left the country by lawful means, so it is not really a question of Italy "boasting" of its "ability to repatriate" unlawfully appropriated items.

It is likening chalk to cheese to compare the preservation of portable antiquities in collections with massive roofless ruins (non-portable antiquities) in the open air. The American mentions the Colosseum, this Flavian building has stood in the centre of the city for coming up to two thousand years. After it went out of use for its original purpose, it has been damaged by earthquakes in Antiquity and stone robbers from Medieval times up to the 18th century. By the 1640s the ruins were so overgrown that a botanist found several hundred species of plants growing on, in and around its walls. Nearly 400 years later then, no wonder that there are problems with slowing down the dynamics of disintegration.



Here's a recent photograph of the Colosseum which illustrates the sort of problems the American's comparison ignores. Instead of sniping, one would have thought the US academic would have made a more useful contribution by coming up with an idea how to protect the fragile ruins already damaged by 2000 years wear and tear from wind, rain, frost, alternate heating and cooling cycles, rising ground water, tourist erosion and all the other effects which threaten these sites. Simply suggesting other countries (scil. his own) hang on to the smaller stolen artefacts does not really seem to me to be very helpful approach to the wider problem.

Phot. Alessandro Bianchi, Reuters

"Metal Detecting" US Civil War Sites

.
Historical writer Robert Grandchamp reviewed on the Civil War News web resource Robert H.C. Alton's book "Stratagem 1861: Early Civil War Tactics and the Battle for the Potomac" dealing with an eight-month bit of the War "between the Union defeat at Bull Run in July 1861 and the beginning of McClellan’s Peninsula Campaign in March 1862". Metal detecting lobbyists were upset by the topic touched on at the end of the review, the reviewer considers that the coverage given to relic hunting "severely detracts from this otherwise interesting work":
Perhaps the most shocking part of the book is the final third, in which Alton delves into the world of relic hunting in Northern Virginia. He describes various Confederate campsites and the relics recovered there. He says they were recovered on private property with permission. As a professional historian, this reviewer believes that artifacts such as these need to be studied by professionals [...]. these sites destroys the context of the artifacts and scholars’ ability to gain access to them as they disappear into private collections. While there is little money available in these tough times to fund professional “digs,” state governments need to provide protection until these sites can be properly studied by professionals instead of being destroyed by amateurs bent on finding the next Confederate belt buckle for their collections.

Obviously metal detector owners in the USA are at a severe disadvantage if they want to look for ancient relics, there aren't any. So they are reduced to searching historical sites for "interesting" things to collect. Over here our hearts bleed for some poor jerk who makes a fool of himself (seen from over here) by posting a You Tube video in which he gets ecstatically excited about finding a diecast metal toy car or 1923 cent. The plundering of old US battlefields for collectables is doubly tragic destruction of potential historic evidence as it was in the US that the use of planned metal detector surveys in battlefield archaeology was pioneered, yet despite the insistence that "metal detecting is good for history" by US collectors' rights lobbyists, it seems not all US metal detectorists are willing to apply best practice to their own activities to ensure that it is. It seems to me that instead of knocking the reviewer for pointing it out, activists for a responsible hobby should be agreeing with what he says about indiscriminate artefact hunting on battlefield sites.

Saturday, 4 February 2012

EBay "does not matter": Lueke and the Coin Elves (Footnote)

.
Coin elf believer Jorg Lueke's searching of ebay figures ('What can [sic] eBay tell us about the Ancient Coin Market (and what it can't)' leads him to believe that "only" 7000 lots containing ancient coins are sold by US-based dealers through eBay a month (that is still some 90 000 a year). He suggests that "90% are coins under $100, [...] 78% are under $50".
Most of the lots, not surprisingly, are Roman Imperial which is the series with the largest amount of junk coins. Since Roman Imperial junkers are ultra common and not part of any US MOUs, though some would be claimed as Italian patrimony, one wonders if they can really be considered cultural property at all. These coins certainly wouldn't be found in any museum and they are unlikely to be making any looters rich.
Mr Lueke seems to have very limited experience of real museums. The research collections of many of them do indeed contain a large number of what he dismisses as "Roman Imperial junkers". This is what many of the hoards added to museum collections through Britain's Treasure Act consist of for example.

Mr Lueke seems to consider that only items of high commercial value and which "make looters rich" can "really be considered cultural property". He either is simply ignorant of the fact, or chooses to ignore it, that the digging of a coin that he dismisses as Roman "junk" from a crucial part of the archaeological record does as much damage to the site, its stratigraphy and thus the potential historical knowledge it contains, as if the coin was worth 5000 dollars to his Minnesota dealer mates.

Thank goodness therefore that articles 1 and 13d of the 1970 UNESCO Convention leave the definition of what is and what is not cultural property up to the source country and not a bunch of greedy self-serving dealers and collectors in the "market country".

Weiss’ Donations to Rhode Island School of Design Museum of Art

.
While the American Numismatic Society is busily trying to expunge from its public records the generous donations made by one of its patrons over the years, not all of the organizations with which Dr Weiss was associated are as alacritous to prematurely proclaim the accused "guilty" and draw a veil of secrecy over such associations. The Chasing Aphrodite blog has a post ('Arnold Peter Weiss’ 46 donations to RISD Museum of Art') detailing 46 objects donated to the museum between 1997 and 2010, 16 of them ancient coins. Some of these items have above-average collecting histories, linking them to named finds and named collectors., which shows that as a collector Weiss was eager and able to obtain this information from his suppliers. As the "Chasing Aphrodite" blog authors note however in not all cases does that unequivocally legitimise the object. as they are either directly or indirectly linked to dealers whose names come up in the ongoing Italian investigation. Nevertheless the publication of these details is welcome and this is a pattern which other prominent institutions like the ANS should be following.

Friday, 3 February 2012

EBay, Lueke and the Coin Elves (Part 2)

.
In his pursuit of what is being written by preservationsists about the scale of the US market for dugup coins, Tie-dye coin elf believer Jorg Lueke has been doing some searching of ebay figures ('What can [sic] eBay tell us about the Ancient Coin Market (and what it can't)' ):
eBay has been used to demonstrate the scope of the ancient coin market both at SAFE and on numerous occasions in front of the CPAC (Cultural Property Advisory Committee). Oddly the amount of thought that has been put into the numbers has been lacking and I aim to correct this oversight.
The clarity of his manner of communicating the results of his "thinking" however leaves a lot to be desired. He says that in order to find out how many coins (for it is just that topic which he is discussing) are being offered on eBay: "we have to differentiate between every lot on eBay and the actual volume of sales". No, no we do not, these are just two aspects of the issue. The number of coins dug up and put on sale is important, not just the turnover of dealers. Unless of course one believes that the coins that are not sold were not dug up but put there by the coin elves. Thus it is that Lueke dismisses as totally unimportant and unrelated to the issue of the scale of the depletion of the archaeological record that "when I just browse ancient coins I see 27973 lots".

His reasoning seems to be that many of these coins can be on offer on eBay "for months as well as many lots that do not sell". So he is proposing that there is a smaller number of fresh coins coming onto the market and being sold among a mass of some 20 000+ coins (see below) which simply lurk unsold on eBay week after week, month after month. Later on, Lueke presents information on what (in his opinion) sells and what does not - you would think that all those dealers spending time and money listing all those 20 000 coins with pictures and sometimes cutesy bits cut-and-pasted from Wikipedia would have worked that out for themselves and saved themselves the effort, eh?

In fact one might wonder about a retailer that stays in business despite the fact that they seem, like three shops near my home, never to sell anything. In the case of the shops near my home it seems to me that the retail outlet is a front for other activities - which could included laundering dirty money. So what is the reason why coin dealers keep offering the same stuff week after week, if it is obvious that there is no market for them? What would be the connection between such a 'dead weight' of surplus-to-market-needs-coins and the appearance of freshly surfaced (from 'underground') coins on the market? Is it not the case that the dead weight to which Lueke draws attention is there to mask the appearance of coins of less-than-licit origins on a market and to justify the view that "there are so many coins we cannot be expected to differentiate old stock from new"?

Anyway, to cut a long story short, Lueke discovers that if he looks at "sold lots" instead of active auctions "the volume in the ancient coin category is a bit less than 3500 lots per week" on EBay globally (at least I think that is what he's getting at). Then his text gets really confusing. The (whole eBay-served) "European market" is either (he says) the same size as the American market [USA pop. 213 million, EU 503 million] or, in another place the market in "Europe" is twice or three times that in America. Let us recall the fact that Lueke omits, that of course most of these ancient dugup coins are being dugup in Europe and adjacent areas and those that come on the market are being collected by collectors within the source countries, or region. Ancient Greek and Roman coins tend not to be dug up very much in North America. Although the lots "originated in the US" the coins in them did not. Lueke says that:
Still we have about 1750 ancient coin lots per week sold in the US and some of those are probably imported recently and some of the lots outside the US probably found owners inside the US.
So what Lueke is saying is that "only" 7000 lots containing ancient coins are sold by US-based dealers through eBay a month (that is still some 90 000 a year). That is apparently meant to arouse in us warm fuzzy feelings about coineys and rush out in a desire to cuddle a collector today. Ninety thousand dugup ancient coins sold in the US is still ninety thousand needless holes, big or small, in the archaeological record, and the tens or more likely hundreds of thousands of unsold surpulus-to-market-needs coins to which Lueke draws attention are another several tens or hundreds of thousands of needless holes in the archaeological record.

Unless of course you believe in coin elves.

Thursday, 2 February 2012

EBay, Lueke and the Coin Elves (Part 1)

.
It seems the coineys have it in for Professor Nathan Elkins, an academic numismatist who sides with the Preservationist White Hat guys rather than with the no-questions-asked antiquities buyers and sellers. First to start the mud-slinging was bitter Old Man Sayles, copied by Jorg Lueke on his "A Historical Perspective" ("exploring history and how it is crafted, manipulated, and used by governments, agencies, and others") blog. When however challenged to formulate and back up his views more precisely, he now claims that what he wrote was "satire". Lueke now follows up his ("satirische") Schlammschlachten, ja, ja with an exposition ("Archaeologist finds all the "evidence" he needs on Ebay") about why what we can see on eBay in fact does not show what it seems to show. Once again this is focussed on the person of "Dr. Nathan T Elkins an Assistant Professor of Art History at Baylor":
In a recent appearance focusing on the cultural property of Bulgaria Dr. Elkins displays a fondness for using Ebay as a source for his arguments. This comes as no surprise as Dr. Elkins used Ebay as a research tool when he wrote his article “Why Coins Matter”. This fondness for superficial results from Ebay opens up several interesting questions that I shall examine.
Having said that of course, the coiney does not. Now, Nathan Elkins has been looking into the US trade on ancient coins for a number of years, and from what I know of that research (which I venture to suggest is considerably more than what Jorg Lueke knows about his research) I would not say that his conclusions are based on "superficial results from Ebay". That is the first straw man argument offered by coiney Lueke.

Coiney Lueke indicates that in his opinion on the extremely rare occasions a seller of dugup ancient coins gives the information from which country they came, it would be "a rather naïve belief [...] that eBay sellers are in all cases telling the truth and not simply marketing what they think will work". In other words' Lueke has no problem accepting that collectors of ancient coins in the US and elsewhere are being lied to by the dealers selling them. Given an awareness of that level of deceit, in what way could that person then turn round and say this is a "legitimate market"? Why would somebody lie about coins coming "from Bulgaria", instead of admitting they come from which country?

Mr Lueke suggests that the number of coins actually being sold by eBay is less than the number presented by Nathan Elkins (nota bene NOT in his comments on the Bulgaria MOU but in several articles on the more general issues connected with the US trade in dugup coins). Lueke suggests we should note how many coins are SOLD rather than the number offered from sale. Presumably he considers that the ones not sold any given week are the ones that fell off trees or were produced by the coin elves and did not come out of the ground, so they are irrelevant to the question about the damage caused by the no-questions-asked market masking looting. But it is not just eBay is it? Let us then note that in parallel venues are also relatively high numbers of coins offered for sale. Just one example is the ACCG's old fried: V-coins (today: "160 Ancient Dealers, 98,940 Items, $22,743,591" - all produced by the coin Elves no doubt).

As it happens, today there are
26,725 results to be found in the category "Coins ancient" on eBay.com. If we narrow that down to those located only in the US, the result is "16,359 results" - so today 61% of the global trade in such items is being done out of the USA (a country whose soil does not as a rule produce ancient coins). Lueke himself notes that when he looks for coins produced in the Roman mint Serdica (mainly supplied the Balkan region and limes, but these coins also reached Britannia) "most of those are already in the US".

The figures for eBay sales of such items today are far higher than the number "5000 a week" mentioned by Elkins and now criticised by Lueke. Yes, it is true that not all those coins are sold from week to week, while some with "buy it now" prices will have gone well before we open the page to look. The feedback for many sellers shows the number of items week after week, month after month. This is (part of ) the turnover of the market, obviously many more items need to be added to the market every week and month to produce the stock from which clients with different needs and financial abilities select what they fancy. Many US dealers have stock which extends far beyond what they put on sale on the Internet any given day, week or month.

What one can see happening on the Internet is not just an array of (superficial) "figures" used to "support" any arguments. This is information anyone can see for themselves when they open the eBay page (or any other dealer's list, or "uncleaned bulk lots of coins" sales sites and discussion lists, of which there are many). However you spin those numbers, they do not reflect too well on the trade when you see how many of them are offered with any sort of information where they came from or any sort of expressly-worded guarantee offered by the seller that he only offers coins where there is due diligence done to ascertain that these are not freshly surfaced coins from recent looting and smuggling, but material he can demonstrate to the buyer has a documented history of licit acquisition and legal export (and legal import into the US).

Looking at the sorry array of sales offers giving no such guarantees (let alone offering potential customers any information about the documentation of legal collecting history and export) and comparing that with what (in the situation this market finds itself in) a truly legitimate market in such material should look like in the second decade of the twenty-first century can readily lead the onlooker to certain conclusions.

Lueke says:
In my view there is no rationale for believing the figures hastily printed off of (sic) eBay and woven (sic) around in front of some bureaucratic committee [i.e., CPAC PMB]. Even if true the story this volume of coins would (sic) tell about a marketplace, one that doesn’t exist in reality, would be contradictory at best [...] all these numbers are make believe and created just to serve a pre-defined purpose: to make it harder to collect coins [...] these numbers are hogwash and I will shortly present a more rational analysis of the current market.
It is unclear why Lueke says there is no "marketplace" for ancient coins when he himself makes use of it to add to his own collection. Anyway, we await with bated breath his promised analysis of the figures to show that the Coin Elves do not really put all that many undocumented ancient coins on the US market.

Wednesday, 1 February 2012

Another Unprofessional PAS FLO Attack


.
Norfolk (Norwich)  metal detectorist liamnolan, one of the moderators of  metaldetectingforum.co.uk in a thread "Re: MD and Archaeology" has this to say (Sun Jan 22, 2012 9:24 pm):
That Paul Barford nonsense is absolute rubbish and in a minute I will be removing the link as it strengthens his site every time someone clicks on it.
Yes, go on, we cannot have metal detectorists looking at a blog which sets metal detecting in a wider context can we? We might get some of them thinking, and we can't have that, can we? (The link was indeed censored). Mr Nolan continues his comments about me:
He is ridiculed by our FLO and is seen by every archaeologist I have met as an embarrassment to how they get on with the detecting community. Don't even think for a minute that he represents the average archaeologist.  
The apparent lack of professionalism of the staff the PAS employ never ceases to amaze. This is by no means the first time comments have been made in a public venue about the criticisms of my ideas by PAS FLOs, but always at second hand. The "our FLO" for Norfolk is Mary Chester-Kadwell, whom I have never met. I have recently had occasion to discuss in print what she has written on the value of information gained from metal detectorists, though in disagreeing with her conclusions, unlike her own reported behaviour, I hope I exhibit a higher degree of professionalism, certainly I restricted my attention to what she wrote and what it means rather than who she "is". Maybe if the staff of the Portable Antiquities Scheme have issues with what I write about artefact hunting and collecting here, they would like to address them openly, say what they think of what I write to my face rather than continually behind my back.

Vignette: Mary Chester-Kadwell of the Portable Antiquities Scheme, according to 'Liam Nolan' prefers ridiculing other people behind their backs with her metal detecting "partners" to open debate about artefact hunting.
 
Creative Commons License
Ten utwór jest dostępny na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa-Bez utworów zależnych 3.0 Unported.